Liberty vs. the Leviathan: Washington Can’t Tell a Factory From a Furnace
You and I know what happens to a lot of the plastic we toss in the blue bin: it never gets recycled at all. By EPA’s count, less than one in ten pounds of plastic in America gets recycled. The rest gets buried, burned, or shipped somewhere else to become someone else’s problem.
Too often, recycling advocates have looked to mandates and subsidies to solve this problem.
The good news: American ingenuity has an answer. It’s called advanced recycling, and it’s one of the most promising kinds of advanced manufacturing in the country. Your recycling bin turns a lot of plastic away. Advanced recycling doesn’t. It breaks that plastic down into its basic building blocks so it can be rebuilt into new products, again and again.
There’s just one problem. Washington can’t decide whether these plants are factories or furnaces.
A 2005 rule is grading a 2026 technology.
Under Section 129 of the Clean Air Act, incinerators face some of the strictest rules on the books. When EPA wrote its rules for “other solid waste incinerators” back in 2005, it swept in something called “pyrolysis/combustion units.” Pyrolysis just means heating something without oxygen, so it breaks apart instead of catching fire, much like a pressure cooker breaks down a tough cut of meat without burning it. In plain English, that means heating material without oxygen so it breaks down rather than burns.
The agency was describing a particular kind of two-chamber incinerator. But pyrolysis is also the core process many advanced recyclers use today, and the label stuck. So a plant built to turn old plastic into new raw material can find itself regulated like the very thing it was designed to replace. It’s a bit like regulating your neighborhood bakery as a crematorium because both have ovens.
Welcome to regulatory ping-pong.
The Leviathan doesn’t just make bad rules. It makes them unpredictable. In 2020, EPA proposed clarifying that pyrolysis units aren’t incinerators. In 2023, a new administration withdrew that proposal. This March, EPA circled back again, tucking a single paragraph about advanced recycling into a 17-page notice about burning wood and yard waste.
Comments closed May 4. EPA says it is reviewing them, and it has set no date for a dedicated rule. Three administrations, three answers, and still no final word. If you were deciding whether to build a new plant, would you bet on a rule that flips every time the White House changes hands?
That isn’t a hypothetical. EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin has said nearly 90 potential advanced recycling facilities are ready to be built across the country but are being held back by regulatory uncertainty. That’s not a technology problem. That’s a Leviathan problem.
We know this works because it’s already working. Just down the Gulf Coast in Baytown, Texas, one advanced recycling plant has been running since 2022 and can now process roughly 250 million pounds of plastic waste a year. Imagine what 90 more could do if Washington got out of the way.
The states have already figured this out.
About half of the states now treat advanced recycling as manufacturing rather than waste disposal, and Louisiana is one of them. These states didn’t toss out environmental protection. They simply put these plants in the right category: a facility that takes in raw material and turns out a product someone wants to buy is a factory.
Even EPA agrees with the logic. The agency has said that when an advanced recycling unit makes a salable product, it generally isn’t processing solid waste. The federal rulebook just hasn’t caught up with EPA’s own reasoning.
Congress can end the guessing game.
Several bills have been introduced in Congress to try and solve this problem. The bills would let advanced recyclers seek to be excluded from the Clean Air Act’s definition of a solid waste incineration unit, putting federal law in line with what most states already recognize. More than two dozen free-market and taxpayer groups have backed it.
Critics say this lets polluters off the hook. It doesn’t. Plants treated as manufacturing still answer to federal clean air standards, under the part of the Clean Air Act built for industrial facilities. The question isn’t whether these plants are regulated. It’s whether they’re regulated as what they actually are.
This is a Louisiana opportunity.
Few states know manufacturing like we do. We have the workforce and the industrial know-how to turn raw materials into products the world wants. Whether advanced recycling plants get built here, or anywhere in America, comes down to whether the rules make sense.
Advanced recycling does not need subsidies; it needs modern rules. A clear, updated regulatory framework is what lets companies build, invest, and hire. Let markets do the work. Government’s job is to set clear rules and get out of the way.
Advanced recycling is worth getting right.