Congress Shouldn’t License Louisiana’s Small Tax Preparers Out of Business
Every spring, Louisiana families have the opportunity to hand their W-2s and receipts to a preparer they know. They could be a neighbor who does returns on the side, a bookkeeper in a strip-mall office, or a small firm that has served the same customers for decades; in each case, their services help alleviate what is often a stressful time for taxpayers. A new provision in a U.S. tax bill is poised to hit those independent tax preparers with a regulatory burden in the form of occupational licensing.
The Taxpayer Assistance and Service Act (S. 5441) passed the Senate on September 30. Most of it focuses on IRS customer service and modernization—things that could benefit Americans. Section 504 is the exception: a concession to Senator Ron Wyden in order to gain the support of Senate Democrats. It sets up a federal licensing system for independent tax preparers, requiring up to 18 hours of continuing education each year for anyone who isn’t already a CPA, attorney, or enrolled agent.
This requirement applies regardless of how long someone has prepared returns or whether a single complaint has ever been filed against them. Due to the detrimental impact it would have on Louisianans across the state, the Pelican Institute has joined a national coalition asking Speaker Mike Johnson to keep Section 504 out of any year-end legislation.
Based on IRS data compiled by the coalition, 10,138 Louisiana preparers would fall under the new mandate, which is 77 percent of the state’s registered preparers—a higher share than every state except Mississippi.
At 18 hours apiece, Louisiana preparers would collectively spend 182,484 hours a year in required coursework instead of serving clients. Nationwide, roughly 485,000 preparers, about 60 percent of the total, would be subjected to this requirement.
Many of them are very small operations. Sole proprietors make up close to half the industry, and the median sole proprietor files only 26 returns a year. For someone working at that scale, two-plus days of annual coursework and the fees that come with it may simply not be worth it.
Anyone paid to prepare federal returns today must register with the IRS, pass a screening that looks at criminal history and personal tax compliance, and list a Preparer Tax Identification Number (PTIN) on every return. Misconduct can bring steep fines and prison time.
In other words, the IRS already knows who is preparing returns and can trace problems back to them. The gap has been enforcement. The IRS opens only about 200 criminal cases a year, and a 2018 Treasury Inspector General audit concluded the agency had no coordinated plan for addressing preparer misconduct.
We’ve seen this play out before. When the IRS tried to impose its own testing and education rules on preparers in the early 2010s, more than 200,000 left the field.
Fewer preparers means less competition, and less competition means higher fees for the families who use them. Some preparers won’t quit but will stop registering and keep working off the books. The IRS calls these “ghost preparers” and already warns taxpayers to avoid them, because they don’t sign the returns they prepare and are hard to track. A rule sold as a fraud-fighting measure could make fraud harder to catch.
The winners under Section 504 would be large tax-prep chains and credentialed professionals. They are either exempt or best positioned to absorb the cost. The bill even lets uncredentialed “supervised preparers” skip the PTIN requirement entirely, as long as a CPA, attorney, or enrolled agent oversees their work.
If Congress wants to root out dishonest preparers, it should direct the IRS to use the authority it already has. That entails going after ghost preparers, raising penalties for them, and using modern data tools, such as artificial intelligence, to flag suspicious filing patterns.
Licensing should be reserved for work where public health and safety are actually at stake, and preparing a tax return doesn’t meet that standard. The Pelican Institute urges Speaker Johnson and Louisiana’s congressional delegation to keep Section 504 out of any end-of-year package and stand with the thousands of Louisiana entrepreneurs who help their neighbors file every year.